According to a video circulating on the internet, it took less than 15 seconds from the time two officers got out of their car, ordered Renee Good to get out of her car, and a different ICE agent to shoot and kill her. This incident happened in Minneapolis on January 7, 2025.
While damning–viewers can clearly see that the agent who shot into Good’s vehicle had time to draw his weapon, fire, move to the side of the vehicle and fire two more shots–the video is not the whole story. But it is part of the story. The officer who fired the shots was not hit by Good. A second officer, the one who likely had most of Good’s attention in the moment, had a hold of Good’s car door in an attempt to open it, after shouting an expletive laden order for her to get out of her car. Even though he had reached into Good’s SUV (assumedly to try to unlock the door) he was not pulled off balance or harmed when Good pulled away; he was merely able to let go of the door.
At the start of the longest version of the video I have seen, Good waits in her already running vehicle while a different SUV pulls in front of her and drives away. A gesture out her open window seems to indicate she is allowing another vehicle to pass. When instead that vehicle stops and two ICE agents get out of their truck and begin yelling at Good the tension of the situation escalates. One can assume Good’s main focus is on those officers but we cannot see her face or hear anything she may be saying. For no apparent reason, one or both of the officers (it’s difficult to tell despite multiple viewings of the video) ordered Good to get out of her SUV. Good was not blocking the road as evidenced by the vehicle that drove around her and she was willing to let other vehicles pass as evidenced by her hand gesture. As Good pulled away she made a wide enough turn to avoid the open driver’s side door of a car parked next to her on the passenger’s side of her car. She also turned away from the officer grabbing her door. And as I’ve already stated, the officer who shot her had time to move out of the way of her vehicle. It is my studied opinion that, during the entire video, Renee Good posed no actual threat to anyone around her.
When I said the video was not the whole story I meant a couple different things. First, we must insist that the Minneapolis Police Department conduct a thorough investigation of this shooting. If left to the Feds, given the administration is already lying about the situation, justice is unlikely to be served. Peaceful legal watch protestors must be allowed to continue to show up and record what ICE and Border Patrol agents are doing. It is a right guaranteed by the Constitution of the United States. And, entire communities must have these watchdogs’ backs. That said, the second thing I meant by the video doesn’t tell the whole story is that we must organize to take back our democracy.
In order to get justice, State and City Police must investigate alleged illegal behavior on the part of ICE and Border Patrol agents. We cannot leave it to the Feds. Sadly, the shooting of Marimar Martinez by a Border Patrol agent in Chicago is a case in point. This incident was only investigated by the Feds and Martinez (who was shot five times) and Anthony Ian Santos were the ones brought up on charges. When the case against them was dropped a month later, with prejudice, it was reported that Agent Exum had bragged in a text to friends that he shot Martinez five times and caused seven holes, ending his text with, “Put that in your books boys”. Cases like this, showing heightened violence and aggression toward immigrants and peaceful protestors, are becoming more and more frequent and, of equal importance, they expose a federal agency out of control. We must insist that State and Local authorities protect our communities and stand in solidarity with peaceful protests. Their jobs are to protect and serve their communities.
BUT, it is not enough to defend our friends, families, and community members against wrong doing. We MUST go on offense! It is time to organize, to elect people who represent the will of the people and who will hold authorities accountable at the federal as well as the state level. If we don’t build a strong offense our defenses will become exhausted, demoralized, and less and less effective. It’s not enough to drive down the lane. We must have leaders who are willing to work together and take the shot. We aren’t going to score every time but we will never win if we fail to get in the game!







